Exercise 2.1: Exploring the Real Universe 

 

The Las Campanas Redshift Survey is a catalog of the redshifts of some 25,000 galaxies. Can you spell out in a few well-chosen words the nature of this project? What is the goal, and what are the techniques? In particular, why survey the Universe in "slices"? Why not survey an entire sphere of galaxies centered on the Earth?

If rich clusters of galaxies contain 1000 galaxies each, and such clusters are 50 million light years apart, how many galaxies lie within a billion light years? If each galaxy needed a 5 minute exposure to get a spectrum, how long would a survey of this volume take? Can you put that in (pre)historical perspective?

How does this compare with the older CFA (Center for Astrophysics, Harvard) survey and with the SDSS (Sloan Digital Sky Survey)?

Below are plots showing different slices of The Las Campanas Redshift survey. The first plot shows one slice, the second shows two slices, etc.

slice1.jpg (68053 bytes)   slice2.jpg (77375 bytes)   slice3.jpg (91486 bytes)

slice4.jpg (86967 bytes)   slice5.jpg (100696 bytes)   slice6.jpg (108554 bytes)

Why bother with six slices? Below are plots showing rotated views of the 6-slice plot. The first shows the slices made North of our Galaxy's disk (red, green and blue) almost edge on, and the second shows the slices South of our Galaxy's disk (magenta, cyan and black) almost edge on. 

ngpedge.jpg (101762 bytes)   sgpedge.jpg (78707 bytes)

Why is it valuable for a survey to have some slices close together, but others far separated?

The next image shows the all six slices in an orientation such that the North slices appear face on:

ngpface.jpg (108204 bytes)

It does not matter which slice you look at -- there are way fewer galaxies far from the apex (that's where we are!) than near by. Does it really seem likely that the density of galaxies is less far from our own?

Next, consider the black slice alone: 

blkface.jpg (71014 bytes)

The image has been oriented so that you see the slice face on. Zoom in:

blkfacezm1.jpg (42624 bytes)

How would you describe the structure that you see? Compare this to a sponge and to a raisin muffin -- what is the difference between a journey from any fiber of sponge to any other fiber of sponge on the one hand, and from raisin to raisin on the other? Try exploring another region:

blkfacezm2.jpg (41920 bytes)

In general terms, is the structure the same?

The next image shows a zoomed in region dense with galaxies near to the apex. Notice the empty area:  

blkfacebub.jpg (37937 bytes)

This a a void -- the equivalent of the air in a sponge, encompassed by the sheets and filaments of the sponge itself. The axes are velocity of recession in km/s. Can you use a value of the Hubble constant -- say 70 km/s/Mpc to estimate a size for the void? How does this compare with the size of our Local Group of galaxies, the distance to the Virgo cluster, and the size of the Local Supercluster?

The plots below show successive zoomed views of a large feature in the un-zoomed black slice:  

blkfacewall1.jpg (42004 bytes)   blkfacewall2.jpg (36425 bytes)

How confident are you that this really is a single structure, and not just a chance alignment of galaxies? Using the same approach as you adopted for the voids, estimate the size of this structure to get an idea of the typical size of sheets and filaments in our Universe.

This final image shows a zoomed-in view of the structure near the apex of the black slice:. 

blkfacefg.jpg (46466 bytes)

Can you identify any small chains of galaxies that appear to point towards the apex? These are the so-called "fingers of god". Can you explain these? Hint: remember that we are plotting speed of recession; what is the difference in speed between those galaxies closest to the apex and those furthest from the apex in one of these chains? How does that compare with the speed with which galaxies move around in a cluster?


If you have access to a good plotting program, such a Matlab, then it would be worth your time to explore the Las Campanas redshift data for yourself. If you are feeling adventurous, download the data files below, which are in the following format:

x1 x2 x3

y1 y2 y3

    .

    .

    .

datangc1.txt

datangc2.txt

datangc3.txt

datasgc1.txt

datasgc2.txt

datasgc3.txt

The first (last) three are data slices of the sky north (south) of the galactic plane.


Home     Links     Exercises